5 Common Instagram Mistakes That Are Hurting Your Engagement (And How to Fix Them)

Listen on Apple | Listen on Spotify | Listen Everywhere

Show Notes

Struggling to get engagement on Instagram? You’re not alone! In this episode of The Creative Bodega, I’m breaking down the five biggest Instagram mistakes solopreneurs make—and how to easily fix them. If you're tired of posting consistently with little results, this episode is for you. Learn how to optimize your bio, improve your captions, diversify your content, and engage with your audience in a way that builds real connections and leads to sales.

Things I cover inside the episode:

✨ Why posting without a clear message is hurting your reach—and how to fix it.
✨ How to craft captions that get your audience to engage (instead of scrolling past).
✨ The biggest engagement mistake most solopreneurs make (hint: stop posting and ghosting).
✨ Why using the same content format repeatedly is limiting your growth.
✨ How to elevate your visuals with high-quality Canva templates for better results.

Episode Breakdown:

00:00 Introduction and Importance of Engagement
00:42 The Biggest Instagram Mistakes That Hurt Your Growth
02:15 Why Posting Without a Clear Message is a Problem
04:10 The Power of a Strong Instagram Bio
06:30 Crafting Captions That Convert
08:45 The Cost of Ignoring Engagement
11:20 Why You Need Content Variation
14:10 The Role of High-Quality Graphics in Engagement
17:00 Final Tips and Encouragement

Are you posting consistently on Instagram but not seeing the engagement, growth, or results you want? It can be incredibly frustrating to put in the effort and feel like nothing is clicking. If you're struggling with low engagement, it's time to reassess your strategy.

Chances are, you might be making one (or more) of these common Instagram mistakes. The good news? They’re all fixable. In this post, we’ll break down the five biggest mistakes solopreneurs and small business owners make on Instagram—and, more importantly, how to correct them for better engagement and conversions.

Mistake #1: Posting Without a Clear Message

One of the most common issues I see is content that lacks clarity. As solopreneurs, we are so close to our businesses that we often assume our audience understands what we do and how we can help them. But without a clear brand message, your audience may feel lost.

✨ How to Fix It:

• Optimize your Instagram bio. Your bio should clearly state who you are, what you do, and how you help. Avoid cluttering it with irrelevant personal details.

• Use SEO in your name field. Instead of a vague name, use keywords your ideal client would search for (e.g., “Canva Expert & Content Coach” instead of “Content Queen”).

• Include a clear call to action. Direct people to their next step, whether it's downloading a freebie, booking a call, or visiting your website.

📌 Resource: Free Instagram Bio Optimization Training

Mistake #2: Writing Weak Captions (Or Having No Strategy at All)

Captions are an essential part of Instagram marketing. Some business owners either overload captions with too much text or keep them too short, like “Happy Friday!”—neither of which encourages engagement.

✨ How to Fix It:

• Match your caption length to the post type. If it's a detailed carousel, keep the caption short. If it's a single image, use the caption to tell a compelling story.

• Break up long captions with line breaks or bullet points for easy reading.

• Use AI tools like ChatGPT to refine your captions and make them more engaging.

• Always include a clear call to action, such as asking a question or encouraging a comment.

Mistake #3: Ignoring Engagement (AKA Posting and Ghosting)

Posting content and then disappearing is a huge missed opportunity. Engagement is a two-way street, and your audience will feel ignored if you're not responding to comments or DMs.

✨ How to Fix It:

• Spend 10-15 minutes, 2-3 times daily, replying to comments and engaging in DMs.

• Use a timer (like this one: Insert Amazon link here) to stay focused and avoid mindless scrolling.

• Leverage voice DMs to make interactions more personal and stand out from competitors.

Mistake #4: Using the Same Content Format Over and Over

You limit your reach and engagement potential if you rely solely on one content type (e.g., only reels or carousels).

✨ How to Fix It:

• Diversify your content:

  • Reels for reach and quick engagement.

  • Carousels for in-depth education.

  • Static photos for storytelling and personal branding.

  • List posts for high shareability.

• Test new formats and analyze what performs best with your audience.

Mistake #5: Using Low-Quality Graphics

If your graphics are poorly designed or contain too much text, they will likely get scrolled past.

✨ How to Fix It:

• Use Canva templates created by professionals instead of designing from scratch.

• Keep headlines clear and compelling. Instead of “My Top 10 Business Tools,” use “10 Must-Have Business Tools for Solopreneurs.”

• Maintain brand consistency with fonts, colors, and layouts.

📌 Resource: Check out The Content Coven Membership

Final Thoughts: How to Improve Your Instagram Strategy

Instagram success isn’t just about showing up—it’s about showing up strategically. If you recognize yourself making any of these mistakes, don’t worry! Start by picking just one to focus on this week and track your progress.

Which of these mistakes do you think you’re making? Drop a comment below!

• Free Instagram Bio Optimization Training

• My Favorite Visual Timer for Focused Work

• Check out The Content Coven Membership